From Control to Conversation: How PINK by Victoria’s Secret Uses the Groundswell to Rebuild Its Brand

Understanding the Groundswell

Charlene Li and Josh Bernoff define the groundswell as a social trend in which people use technologies to get what they need from each other rather than from traditional institutions. Instead of companies controlling messaging, consumers now participate, respond, critique, and even shape brands themselves. As discussed throughout The Groundswell, organizations succeed when they stop treating audiences as passive viewers and begin treating them as collaborators in conversation. Chapter 10 emphasizes that transformation happens when companies “become so engaged with your customers that you walk in step with their needs and wants,” shifting from product-centered communication to customer-centered relationships.

A strong, modern example of this transformation can be seen in PINK, Victoria’s Secret's youth-focused sub-brand. Once associated with traditional, top-down advertising and unrealistic beauty standards, the brand has increasingly relied on social media engagement, influencer culture, and audience participation to reconnect with Gen Z consumers.



PINK and the Shift Toward Social Media Conversation

Historically, Victoria’s Secret marketing relied almost solely on its presentation. For instance, it's famous fashion shows, extra small supermodels, and tightly controlled brand messaging. However, as social media has reshaped consumer expectations, this model began to fail, and Victoria's Secret could no longer rely on spectacles. Consumers were no longer satisfied with glamorous and sultry imagery alone; they wanted authenticity, representation, and interaction.

Although both Victoria's Secret and PINK have used digital media since the early 2010s, in recent years, PINK was the first to test a new approach and became a testing ground for change. Targeting college-aged and Gen Z audiences, the brand began to lean heavily into Instagram, TikTok, and influencer partnerships where consumers actively co-create brand meaning through trends, styling videos, and commentary. Rather than dictating style from the top down, PINK encourages users to showcase how they wear products, turning customers into marketers.

This mirrors a key idea from Chapter 9: successful companies must move beyond broadcasting and instead “energize customers to participate.” User-generated content, campus ambassadors, and creator collaborations help PINK build visibility through peer influence, a core principle of the groundswell.

Social media has also enabled the brand to respond publicly to criticism and evolve its identity. Victoria’s Secret has expanded representation through more diverse models and creators, including partnerships with influencers who reflect broader gender identities and body types, signaling a shift toward inclusivity driven largely by online consumer pressure rather than internal advertising decisions alone (Them).



Applying Chapter 10: Transformation Through Letting Go of Control

Chapter 10 explains that companies transform when they accept that engaging the groundswell requires relinquishing control. The authors note that success comes when organizations “learn to give up control of the brand message” and trust customers to shape conversations themselves.

PINK’s marketing clearly demonstrates this shift. TikTok trends featuring PINK hoodies or loungewear often originate from users rather than corporate campaigns. The brand amplifies these trends instead of scripting them, allowing authenticity to drive engagement. This reflects the Dove example in Chapter 10, where viral success came not from expensive advertising but from content audiences voluntarily shared.

The authors stress that transformation occurs through small steps: “Take small steps that have a big impact.” Victoria’s Secret followed a similar path. After years of declining relevance, the company gradually rebuilt its strategy through social listening, influencer collaborations, and digital storytelling rather than a single dramatic rebrand. Social media became a feedback mechanism that showed what younger audiences valued—comfort, relatability, and individuality.

Listening First: A Lesson from Dell Applied to Fashion



One of the most important lessons from Chapter 10 comes from Dell’s crisis, where the company learned to listen before acting. The authors explain that Dell’s turnaround began when it started monitoring blogs and responding directly to customer concerns, proving that engagement must start with understanding conversations already happening online.

PINK’s current strategy reflects this listening model. Gen Z fashion trends move rapidly through TikTok aesthetics such as Y2K nostalgia, athleisure, and “cozy campus” fashion. Rather than imposing trends, the brand adapts to them — releasing color drops, lounge collections, re-releasing fan favorites, and casual wear aligned with social media aesthetics popular among young consumers. Industry analysis shows legacy youth brands succeeding today are those using influencer activations and social platforms to stay culturally relevant with Gen Z audiences (Traackr).

One clear example of PINK responding to the groundswell is their recent re-release of Y2K-inspired leggings and apparel. Fans had been actively posting on TikTok and Instagram about wanting the “old” PINK clothing back, sharing photos of vintage pieces, styling ideas, and expressing nostalgia for early 2000s campus fashion. By listening to these conversations, PINK recognized a clear demand and responded by bringing back the Y2K collections, essentially letting consumer desire guide product development. This strategy reflects Li and Bernoff’s principle of walking “in step with customer needs and wants” (Li & Bernoff, 2011, Ch. 10), as the brand did not create the trend but amplified and legitimized it. The relaunch also exemplifies the concept from Chapter 9 of energizing customers to participate: consumers were not only buying the products but also creating content around them, further spreading visibility and building peer-driven marketing momentum. In this way, PINK turned nostalgia-driven social media chatter into a tangible product strategy, demonstrating the groundswell in action.

By observing online behavior and responding quickly, PINK practices what the book describes as walking “in step with customer needs and wants.”



Authenticity and Transparency in Social Media PR

Another critical takeaway from Chapter 10 is the importance of authenticity. The authors argue that Dell only gained credibility when it openly admitted mistakes and engaged honestly with critics. Similarly, Victoria’s Secret’s renewed strategy emphasizes relatability rather than unattainable perfection.

Instead of polished runway imagery dominating feeds, PINK now frequently features casual content, influencer storytelling, and lifestyle-focused posts. This shift reflects a broader PR lesson: audiences trust brands that feel human. Social media collapses the distance between company and consumer, making transparency not optional but necessary.

From a communications theory perspective, this aligns with two-way symmetrical communication in public relations, where dialogue, not persuasion alone,  builds long-term relationships.

What the Marketing Industry Can Learn

PINK’s evolution demonstrates several lessons for PR and marketing professionals:

  1. Community drives credibility. Peer content often carries more influence than branded advertising.

  2. Listening is a strategy. Social monitoring provides real-time consumer insight.

  3. Control must be shared. Viral success often comes from audience participation, not corporate planning.

  4. Transformation is gradual. As Chapter 10 explains, organizational change happens through “a series of stepping-stones,” not overnight reinvention.

The brand’s ongoing rebuild shows that even companies with outdated reputations can reconnect with audiences when they embrace the groundswell mindset.


Conclusion

The rise of social media has fundamentally changed how PR and marketing operate. PINK by Victoria’s Secret illustrates how brands must evolve from broadcasting messages to facilitating conversations. By embracing influencer culture, user participation, and authentic engagement, the brand demonstrates the central lesson of The Groundswell: power has shifted to consumers.

As Li and Bernoff emphasize, companies succeed when they stop trying to control customers and instead collaborate with them. In today’s digital environment, marketing is no longer about speaking the loudest — it is about listening the best.



References

Li, C., & Bernoff, J. (2011). Groundswell: winning in a world transformed by social technologies. Harvard Business Press.

Post, W. (2023, April 6). How PINK put purpose at the center of their brand  • dosomething strategic • the experts in gen Z and purpose. DoSomething Strategic . https://dosomethingstrategic.work/insights/pinksocialimpactplatform

Riedel, S. (2022, February 4). This tiktok star just became Victoria Secret’s first black trans model. Them. https://www.them.us/story/emira-dspain-tiktok-star-victoria-secret-first-black-trans-model?utm_source

Stull, J. (2023, October 17). NEW VS adaptive collection: Intimates for women with disabilities. VS Now. https://www.victoriassecret.com/us/vs/vsinsider/brand-values/adaptive

Victoria’s secret fashion show: The power of influencer strategy. (n.d.). Traackr. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.traackr.com/influencer-marketing-blog/victorias-secret-fashion-show-influencer-strategy?utm_source







Comments

  1. Hi Lydia! I liked how you used PINK by Victoria's Secret as an example of the groundswell, especially since you explained it very clearly using content from Li and Bernoff's book. This made me think of their recent collaboration with TWICE and how one of their bras went viral during a fashion show, so PINK listened to the buzz and released a Valentine's collection with them again. Thank you for your sharing your thoughts!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

SWOT Analysis and Recommendations for Glossier

Lessons From Chapters 5 & 6 of The Groundswell